The Billy Mays team, coming from the losers bracket, won the first 5-9 series. It's decided to split 50/50 but have the number 3 and 4 players on each team play one game for first place trophy (with a couple hundred extra dollars to the winner of that game).

1st Ken Storck
Phil Gardner
Jack Davis
Becky Foster
Gilbert Baird
Janice Hagerty

2nd Billy Mays
Harvey Walden
Jim French
Roy Applegate
Barb Head
Joetta Romero

3rd Jeri Williams
Gerald Wood
Sandy Blade
Warren Settegast
Jett Williamson
Tree Cameron

4th Jeff Womble
Mark Gray
Ed White
Gary Hagerty
Phil Copeland
Alban McDonald

11) Tony Pelton
Hoot Hodge
Jim Kennedy
Gary Thompson
Ray Evatt
Joe Avent

12) Jeri Williams
Gerald Wood
Sandy Blade
Warren Settegast
Jett Williamson
Tree Cameron

13) Jeff Womble
Mary Gray
Ed White
Gary Hagerty
Phil Copeland
Alban McDonald

14) David Williams Jr.
Ronnie Campbell Jr.
Lacho Barradas
Craig Bendickson
Joyce Gamble
Bradley Blade

15) Kelly Cameron
Alex Bagdikian
Terry Yingst
Butch Thomas
Anita Bloodworth
Jordan Yingst

16) Al Salazar
Deb Voorhis
Lewis Bailey
Teddy Canada
Carol Audett
Barbie Gray

17) Frank Blade
Jerry Siebert
Jessica Williams
Manny Canada
Glen Tubbs
Rob Weaver

18) Johnny Wayne Crawford
Marty Shepard
Mike Rapp
Sandy Tubbs
Lee Boyajian
Loren Jorgensen

19) Bill Melton
Lee McDonald
Wayne Hammond
Jimmy the Cop
Alice Patterson
Larry Creakbaum

20) Bobby Voorhis
Alfred Suarez
Connie Langolf
Rick Pittman
Frank Edelan
Roland Harkless